Not guilty plea entered in death of motorist in ‘23 crash at Teegarden and 45
LISBON — A West Virginia man entered a not guilty plea Monday to aggravated vehicular homicide and aggravated vehicular manslaughter for allegedly causing the Jan. 30, 2023 crash which led to the Jan. 31, 2023 death of 44-year-old Trevor Lee Reed.
Anthony L. Thornabar, 38, Spencer, W.Va., is scheduled to face a pretrial at 11:15 a.m. Jan. 28 in Columbiana County Municipal Court.
The charges against Thornabar were originally filed in January 2024, but the arraignment didn’t occur until now.
According to the affidavit filed by Ohio State Highway Patrol Trooper Bruce Palmer, the crash investigation found Thornabar at fault for failing to stop or yield prior to entering the intersection of state Route 45 and Teegarden Road.
Thornabar was driving eastbound on Teegarden Road in a 2021 Dodge Ram pickup when he crossed state Route 45 and was struck by a 2012 Nissan Altima driven southbound by Reed, who had the right of way.
The affidavit said the Nissan rotated and struck a guardrail and the Dodge Ram went off of the road, vaulted over a guardrail and over an embankment, striking a group of trees. At the intersection, Teegarden Road has a posted stop sign and painted stop bar to control traffic through the intersection, while traffic on state Route 45 does not have to stop and has the right of way.
“The defendant admitted to not seeing a Nissan Altima/vehicle traveling southbound as he crossed state Route 45,” the affidavit said.
Reed, of Salem, died from his injuries the next day at Mercy Health St. Elizabeth Hospital in Youngstown. According to his obituary, at the time of his death he was survived by two daughters and a son, along with his father and many other relatives, aunts, uncles and cousins.


