Trooper Nicholas P. Cayton

1985-2025

It is with profound sadness that we announce the passing of Trooper Nicholas P. Cayton of the Ohio State Highway Patrol on October 16, 2025. He went to be with the Lord, after giving his life in service to the people of Ohio. Trooper Cayton served on the patrol since 2012 and will be remembered for his courage, commitment, and unwavering dedication to protecting others.

“Nicky” Cayton was born on September 9, 1985 in Canton, Ohio to Duwane Cayton and Cindy Cayton, where he resided in New Harrisburg, Ohio, along with his two sisters, Lainy and Sabrina. He was a 2004 graduate of Carrollton High School, where he played and excelled in football, basketball, and baseball.

Feeling a strong calling to serve his country, Nick joined the Ohio Army National Guard in 2007, while attending Youngstown State University. Nick was deployed twice overseas, first in 2008 to Iraq with the 583rd Military Police Company and then in 2013 to Afghanistan with the 838th Military Police Company and finished his service as a staff sergeant in 2014. In 2010, he completed YSU’s Police Academy and later earned his criminal justice degree. During those years, Nick formed life-long friendships that carried him through deployments and to each stage of his life. Nick earned his gray shirt and Stetson in 2012 when he became a Trooper in the Ohio State Highway Patrol, working first at the Lisbon post, and then transferring to Canfield. Nick was named “Trooper of the Year” for his outstanding service for 2022.

In 2007, Nick married his high school sweetheart, Lynsey. They were together every step of the way and started their family in 2015 with their beloved son, Turner. The apple of his eye, their daughter, Romy, was born in 2017. The greatest joy of his life was being Daddy.

Nick will most definitely never be forgotten. He left a legacy of memes, catchy phrases (mostly inappropriate), dance moves, whistles, and taking over the music at parties (a.k.a. “DJ Nick”). Nick loved the Cleveland Guardians, Columbus Blue Jackets and couldn’t unlove his Cleveland Browns, no matter what. He enjoyed coaching his son and teammates for the Canfield Little Cardinals football team. Nick spent many years playing the bagpipes with the Steel Valley Pipes and Drums and for the State Patrol.

Nick is survived by his wife of 18 years, Lynsey (Stine) Cayton; son, Turner; daughter, Romy; mother, Cindy Cayton; father, Duwane Cayton; sister, Lainy (Cayton) Gooding (Jason, their children Lyza and Josey); sister, Sabrina (Cayton) Simmons (Shawn and their children Kail, Karson, and Kolt), In-laws, Greg and Rhonda Smith; In-laws Sherman and Joyce Stine; Brother-in-laws, Talen Smith (Cara Gainor and sons, Greyson and Carson Bradt), Andy Stine (Kim and sons, Garret and Colin Wright); Nick Stine; Jack Stine (Clea); Grandmother, Kathy Taylor; Grandmother, Donna Savage; and many beloved aunts, uncles, cousins, and friends that were family.

“So, gather up your jackets, move it to the exits, I hope you have found a friend, Closing time, every new beginning, Comes from some other beginning’s end.”

A Celebration of Life Service will be on Wednesday, October 22, 2025, at Beeghly Center, 224 West Spring Street, Youngstown, Ohio 44502. The services will start at 1 p.m., the doors will be opened at noon for seating. It is very important that those attending pay attention to areas that have been designated for parking and specific seating areas.

The family had requested that in lieu of flowers, donations be made to Shop with a Cop program.

Arrangements were entrusted to the care of the Arbaugh-Pearce-Greenisen & Sons Funeral and Cremation Services, Salem.

10/20/25